My Spaniel loves these treats, he appears to much like the crunch and the fact that It's not one bite and long gone. The resealable packet retains them new and crunchy. These are typically a quality treat, properly manufactured with NO synthetic substances and they smell much like peanut butter. https://goodboychickenandsweetpot03580.bloggazzo.com/31029839/indicators-on-duck-deli-bites-dog-treats-goodboy-you-should-know